By Katie Kerwin McCrimmon
The iconic Western cowboy has long enchanted artists and pioneers alike. Who could be more carefree than a man alone on his horse, herding cattle as jagged peaks tower overhead?
The romance with the Rocky Mountain West is fundamental to our American DNA.
Yet, there is a hidden peril for these mavericks and stoic ranchers, as poisonous as cigarettes were to the rugged Marlboro man.
Depression and suicide rates are alarmingly high among ranchers and rural residents in Colorado.
Throughout the state, Colorado has set an unfortunate record with the highest number of suicides ever recorded in state history. Altogether, 940 people took their own lives in 2009, the most recent year for which data is available.
Among the stark statistics:
- The toll marked a 17 percent increase over the next highest year, 2007, and the highest suicide rate per capita in Colorado since 1988.
- Nearly twice as many people died by their own hands last year as those who died in car accidents.
- Almost 80 percent of those who committed suicide were men.
- While the state no longer tracks suicides specifically among ranchers or farmers, the suicide rate is disproportionately high in Colorado’s rural counties.
- While the suicide rate is higher in rural Colorado, the number of suicides is greater in more populated, urban areas.
- Colorado consistently ranks among the top 10 states in the country for suicide.
- In 2007, the last year for which national statistics are available, Colorado had the sixth highest suicide rate in the country.
Now, a new study may help explain the high suicide rates that have long confounded mental health workers in Colorado and the Rocky Mountain West.
Dr. Perry Renshaw, a psychiatrist at the University of Utah’s Brain Institute and an investigator with the Veterans Affairs Rocky Mountain Mental Illness Research, Education and Clinical Center based in both Salt Lake City and Denver, has found a new overwhelming link between high altitude locations and suicide. The study could have profound implications for suicide prevention in Colorado – the state with the highest average altitude in the country.
“At 6,000 feet (above sea level) suicide rates increased by approximately 70 percent. It’s huge,’’ said Renshaw, the lead researcher on the study.
Causes for suicide can be extremely complicated. Renshaw and fellow researchers looked at other risk factors in the region including a high rate of gun ownership and isolation from low population density. Gun ownership is a well recognized contributing factor for suicide and past studies have shown that suicide rates are higher in rural areas. But suicide experts hadn’t ever looked specifically at the impact of altitude on mood disorders.
Oxygen deprivation may worsen depression
The Utah team’s research found that gun ownership and low population density alone could not sufficiently explain increased rates of suicides at higher altitudes. They found that altitude was an independent risk factor. Renshaw cautions that more research needs to be done, but he believes that oxygen deprivation at higher elevations, known as hypoxia, may cause metabolic stress on people with depression and other mood disorders.
“We calculated the altitude for every county in the U.S. and you get this whoppingly high correlation between high altitude and suicide risk,’’ Renshaw said. “The take-home message is that it’s exceedingly unlikely that this would happen by chance. It would be just one chance in a gazillion.”
Veteran suicide researchers remain skeptical about a direct link between high altitude and suicide. Many had theorized that there was something unique about the people drawn to the American West that elevated suicide risk. To test for this, Renshaw and his team looked at data from Korea, a country with varying high-altitude topography similar to the Rocky Mountain region. They found exactly the same trend in a totally different culture.
“The higher you live, the higher the suicide rate was,’’ Renshaw said. “Altitude remains one of the strongest suicide predictors.”
Renshaw decided to study altitude and suicide after moving to Utah a couple of years ago and seeing a map showing the dramatic regional differences in suicide rates. Previously, his research had focused primarily on brain chemistry and mood disorders, not on suicide. He was surprised at how overwhelming and consistent the study results were.
Perhaps even more surprising has been the pushback from veteran suicide researchers and tourism officials who don’t want negative publicity about the Rockies.
“We’re not saying that if you’re depressed and you’re living in the mountains, you should move. That’s a drastic cure. But, we need to think seriously about doing more research to understand this,’’ Renshaw said. “Some people adapt quite well (to altitude). The quality of life is very high. And the vast majority of people love living here. It’s also, to my mind, quite clear that there are some people who don’t do so well.”
“John Wayne mentality” a risk to men
Among Fetsch’s most requested program: “Spotting the Signs of Suicide.”
Fetsch, who has taught for 31 years, blames attitude more than altitude for the high rate of depression and suicide among men in rural areas throughout Colorado. The tough economy has made things harder for men who learned as little boys to be tough and independent, not to seek help.
“There’s a John Wayne mentality. Do it alone. Cowboy it up. Don’t be a sissy,’’ Fetsch said of the pervasive attitude. “We expect men to be the sturdy oak, confident, self-reliant, give ’em hell.’’
That self-reliance can leave men suffering alone and in silence.
“When they’re hurting, men are taught to keep it inside. Tell no one. Be a man,’’ Fetsch said.
After his talks, Fetsch finds men frequently open up to him and share their darkest fears.
“One said to me, ‘I’m 48. I’m the sixth generation rancher on this land and I might be the one who loses it. Can you imagine how horrible I feel?”
Risk of suicide rises as people age. The rate is highest among men over 85. The next most at-risk group is men between ages 45 and 64.
“It’s particularly bad after they lose a spouse or their identity. It may have do with the demands of family farms, the shortage of health care workers in rural areas, high accessibility of firearms, financial difficulties, and retirement is tough for farmers and ranchers,’’ Fetsch said.
Former Logan County Sheriff Bob Bollish, 60, was the quintessential John Wayne-style lawman. He loved riding horses, singing and gazing at puffy clouds and crystal stars. A native of Sterling, Bollish was hoping to become sheriff again when one cold early morning in February, he shot himself to death in his pickup truck on a remote piece of land near his property.
The campaign wasn’t going his way and investigators said Bollish was distraught at having to sell off some of his land to pay bills. He also was facing medical problems that left him in pain.
“His death rocked this community,’’ said Maranda Miller, suicide prevention coordinator for Rural Solutions, a group that promotes health care in 10 rural counties spread out over 17,000 square miles in northeastern Colorado
“Unfortunately, we have very easy access to guns. Being the former sheriff, he was very well versed with firearms,” Miller said.
She conducts suicide prevention classes for groups large and small, ranging from pastors to groups of elderly people. She tries to break down the stigma against seeking mental health care.
Economic problems are just one of many issues that cause people to turn to suicide.
“A lot of small farmers can’t make it out here anymore. If you don’t belong to a large corporation, it’s hard to keep it going. Some people also turn to alcohol, “ Miller said.
Foundation, state of Colorado pour millions into suicide prevention
The Colorado Trust has pumped nearly $4.1 million over the last several years into suicide prevention programs throughout the state, and recently prepared an in-depth study on progress throughout Colorado.
Colorado also boasts an Office of Suicide Prevention to coordinate prevention efforts aimed at vulnerable people from teenagers to retirees.
Among the findings of The Trust’s report:
- While the greatest number of suicide deaths occur in Denver area counties each year, the highest rate of deaths occurs elsewhere in the state.
- Unlike many other health problems that disproportionately affect racial and ethnic minorities, white people are at greater risk for suicide in Colorado than blacks, Hispanics and Native Americans.
- Two factors are strongly related to the rate of death by suicide: higher levels of unemployment and higher proportions of people living in social isolation.
- Nearly half of Colorado teenagers who died by suicide had experienced a personal crisis within the two weeks prior to their death.
- Suicidal youth are also likely to be depressed, abuse alcohol and have a history of aggressive or antisocial behavior
- More than two-thirds of men ages 25-54 who died by suicide experienced depression in the days prior to their death, and a large majority had not sought or received professional help.
- Factors that elevated suicide risk among middle-aged people included loss of a spouse or a child, health problems, financial difficulties and social isolation.
Recently, national attention has focused on increased suicide risks for military veterans, and gay and lesbian teens and young adults. Both young people and soldiers are among those at great risk in rural areas as well.
Paradise may not be paradise; reaching out to save lives
Moffat County in the northwestern corner of Colorado had the unfortunate distinction of posting one of the worst suicide rates in Colorado over a nearly 10-year period between the late 1990s and 2007, according to The Trust study.
Ronna Autrey, herself a suicide survivor after her adult son died in a suicide nine years ago, said newcomers sometimes come to Colorado hoping to solve their problems. Of course, they bring their baggage with them.
“People come here because it’s idyllic and absolutely beautiful,’’ said Autrey, who runs a suicide prevention program called Reaching Everyone Preventing Suicide in Routt and Moffat counties.
“They find that paradise isn’t paradise after all. It’s expensive to live in the mountains. People have to work two and three jobs. We see a lot of shame when men lose jobs. And, we have a lot of ranchers who don’t seek help. They’re used to pulling themselves up by their bootstraps.’’
Autrey said it’s especially hard for people in small towns to seek help. Often in rural communities, the mental health center is a stand-alone building. People are afraid to walk in the door because their friends and neighbors might see them.
“It’s all about the shame,’’ said Autrey.
She tells her story over and over again to try to convince people that talking about depression and seeking help is far better than dealing with the devastation of suicide.
The need for information is clearly there. During a recent information session on bipolar disorder, Autrey had nearly 100 people show up.
“There are tons of people whose lives have been touched by this. They haven’t known where to seek help. The worst stigma is still walking in that mental health building,’’ Autrey said. “We’re definitely saving lives. I just worry about the ones we don’t reach.”